We NEED to talk! LAWSUIT over Skyrim Mod - MxR & The Floating Market by Tarshana

FOLLOWUP VIDEO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BY2Qk9Y3Ekc
The mod is back up on the nexus, but we need to talk about it because this case and cases like it have the potential to affect future mods and mod reviewers its VERY important this topic be discussed. I skimmed over this during my last video of this type, but after taking a little bit of time and hearing what other people had to say on this topic, I felt like it was important that the community was a whole, Mod Makers, Mod Users and not just reddit posters or people behind the safety wall of the Nexus Modders Private forums. This is a topic for EVERYONE, ESPECIALLY mod reviewers, and reviewers of any kind.

The alleged author of the the Floating Market, by the Reddit/Nexus Username of Tarshana according to accounts took MxR to court some time ago and this never reached the majority of people's ears until MxR spoke out on it briefly, but then it wasn't discussed. Many of us have been told that it has been settled out of court, meaning the case is over, but the results NEED to be discussed.

So think of this video as a review of the third-hand information I've gathered thus far about it. We need to talk.
  • Yamnyak King

    Sending death threats to people is unacceptable!

  • Carrigan Sevedge

    Wow... I was going to download this mod until I saw this. I’ll make sure to rate it as low as possible, she’s trash.

  • Zaric Zhakaron

    UPDATE & CONCLUSION TO THIS CONVERSATION: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BY2Qk9Y3EkcEarlier Links and InfoReddit Threads:*https://www.reddit.com/r/skyrimmods/comments/619wy9/whats_up_with_the_drama_surrounding_the_floating/*https://www.reddit.com/r/skyrimmods/comments/63wb7l/ootl_mxr_and_the_floating_market_mod/*https://www.reddit.com/r/skyrimmods/comments/5x6rt7/the_floating_market_31_is_ready_new_textures_bug/*https://www.reddit.com/r/skyrim/comments/6782w9/a_man_reveiws_the_floating_market/Topic on the Nexus Modder's Forums (Can't see it exists unless you have a 1000+ DL mod on your nexus account): *https://forums.nexusmods.com/index.php?/topic/4909260-youtubers-making-money-off-mods/Note, many of the important posts from this have been deleted. Also if you are not logged in as a registered modder the thread and forum will not exist for you.-----------------------------------------MxR:*https://www.youtube.com/user/MMOxReviewMxR Videos talking about this:*https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kp8Oh3fC3k*https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBTIXS2Q3mA-----------------------------------------Floating Market Author:*http://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/users/9100504/The Floating Market Mod:*http://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/7615/

  • Darknight1243

    Wait can a mod author even claim something like this because technically his work belongs to bethesda and zenimax since its a derivative work?

  • Hannah Juhl

    From what I have seen, LPs are generally accepted as Fair Use due to the entertainment and/or review statutes under the Fair Use Agreement.

  • LidiaLeeSun

    Zaric you are totally right (33:52) The mod author who has uploaded 1 mod which included x (x= any number) of mods to a package doesn't own it, doesn't own anything, and instead to be grateful to MxR for the advertising he/she complains. No gamers see the review of a mod or a collection and if they find it interesting even for just a test they will download it, if not they will pass to the next mod etc. MxR didn't done anything wrong as a "journalist" have seen a mod and made a review or article about the mod. Youtubers ,lets use this term, are similar to the journalist for newspapers they show news. You don't kill the messenger if you don't like the message.

  • Sven Tempest

    Just now finding out about this absurdity months after the fact. I am genuinely baffled that anyone would make such a stupid decision over free publicity. One mod author to avoid for sure.

  • Clunk 42

    If I were a mod author, I'd be happy to have my mod featured on a showcase because that would sped the word and allow more people to use my mod.

Skyrim | Tininnus Imperial #2 | Legacy of the Dragonborn Gallery Relic Hunter
[Skyrim Modpack] Classic RPG Style - Character Stats, Classes, De-Levelled World, Random Loot.
Skryim Special Edition (Fully Modded) - Vivid Weathers vs Climates of Tamriel Showcase
Level 251 Character vs The Ebony Warrior - Skyrim
Mod Recommendations for Skyrim Special Edition
SKYRIM - 10 BEST PLAYER HOME MODS
Skyrim - All Unique Bows & Staves
From Paid Mods to Creation Club (THE WHOLE THING) | Skyrim Special Edition: Paid Survival Mod
Skyrim's Most Tragic Story
Skyrim Mods - Week 190 - CAMILLA YOU WHORE
COOKING FALLOUT 4 DISHES! (Radstag Stew and Deezer's Lemonade)
STUPID PEOPLE & NET NEUTRALITY | Your Web Signature means NOTHING | How to actually get Involved
© 2017 Скайрим 5 — Путеводитель по миру игры Скайриму. Видео по теме как заполнить души, мод на огнестрельное оружие - где добыть кровь. Лучшая легкая броня в Скай Риме